Sometimes it is worth a little extra time and effort to get the best. I am not sure. If you accidentally used baking soda your cake would be quite salty. I’m wondering if were using buttermilk in this recipe if we should add a tsp of baking soda to help the rising process. I think she would approve. There have been many commenters that have used a variety of different pans with success. Can this cake be made with All purpose flour and turn out just as moist? Will this cake hold up to being covered in fondant or is it too light & fluffy?L. Stir in the buttermilk and vanilla … Hmmm, strange that the first few times worked great and the last time did not. Thanks! You could double the recipe to have enough although there may be a little batter left over. You can also just skip this and take out in advance to warm up. We use this small amount of oil because it adds extra moisture to the cake. Hi Kim, In the written text above the recipe Melissa list various links to recipes that would pair well with this cake — Classic Vanilla, Classic Chocolate, Cream Cheese. I made this cake today following your recipe and the cake turned out awesome. I also added sprinkles for that extra pop ? That is just our preference. Made this cake for my boyfriend’s birthday and it was a big hit so thank you!! Place one cake layer on a cake serving plate or decorating plate. Hi Nicole I followed your recipe except for I used my favorite vanilla concentrate instead of the Rodelle vanilla. Andi thewednesdaybaker.blogspot.com, That is a great tip about the cake flour. How do I cater this recipe for a three layered cake? I’m definitely keeping this one. She didn’t really want a cake, but was sooo glad that I baked this cake for her after she tasted it! extra.) After all, everything goes with vanilla cake! He wants a white cake with white frosting and strawberries on top. I have been searching for years for a vanilla cake that wasn’t so dry that you needed to have coffee with it just to get it down. How come your the buttercream on your photos are so White? Since I’m going to use this cake for a strawberry cheese cake trifle the density will probably be a bit better for it. I know that if a cake batter has too many eggs it does cause a density issue and possible the color issue as well. Perhaps that will help those that are having issues with the rise. Absolutely a winner! This cake is quite delicate so I would guess No. Transfer cakes to cooling racks. (I was looking for a “tart” cake) Actually my guests spat the cake out, it was embarrassing. You may need to let it sit at room temp for a few minutes to soften slightly before spreading . can I make this in a square pan? Because of the love of lemon in my family, I made a lemon filling. Unfortunately I do not live in an area that ever has much humidity so I cannot test this recipe in that environment. Yes, the butter should be softened (room temp) Thanks for commenting, I will go add that note to the recipe . I honestly think you need to reduce the amount of salt. We have less than 3 cups per pan and our layers are approximately 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 inches tall. Hi! Great Find Thank You!!! Please clarify. I leave in a town where it is humid 365 days a year and I have never had any problems with this cake. I absolutely love this recipe! Allow to cool completely before frosting. In a smaller bowl, whisk together the whole eggs, egg yolks, vanilla, and the remaining 1/3 cup buttermilk until well blended. In a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, whip the butter for 1 minute. Honestly, I never leave all ingredients at room temp, just the butter so that it can be creamed with the sugar. Rodelle Reserve was aged for 6 months in French Oak barrels to enrich the vanilla flavors and soften the harsher alcohol flavor that all extracts inherently have. 2- in uk don’t have cake flour can I use all purpose flour? So long as it still tasted good. I am so happy you enjoyed the recipe, and thank you for posting your review. Thanks. I want to use this as a base for a tres leche. If you only post what you want people to see than itS not a good recipe isn’t it. Hi I just made this cake and it was amazing. Place one layer of cake on a cake stand or serving plate. Hi! I baked this last nite but when I cut it today I find the cake was dense. This cake looks really great. Top with fresh fruit, edible flowers or sprinkles. Even box cake mixes have to be adjusted here. Ah yes, a pastel vanilla sprinkly cake!Hehe. I love this recipe and have made it many, many times. I think I will make this cake with vanilla paste and double it up. Let me know if you give it a try. I tried it and it was wow Awesome! Oh No! I have been asking around for high altitude baking tips and have been referred to this guide several times >> http://www.kingarthurflour.com/learn/high-altitude-baking.html. I consciously kept this cake plain. Would you share how you made it lemon and if you flipped the cake so it could be served on a cake board?? Margarita Cake with Tequila Lime Buttercream, click here to Subscribe without commenting, We are using the traditional method of mixing for this recipe (rather than the. Delicate and fluffy and so damn irresistible by all who tried it! I did not over mix and was on low. But I found this handy egg substitute graphic: http://skillet.lifehacker.com/this-cheat-sheet-shows-the-best-egg-substitutes-for-ba-1684302007?crlt.pid=camp.LC19VlQflIUI. Hi, I want to know if I can use butter for the whole recipe and not vegetable oil, and will baking the cake in two 8inch pan okay. thanks, Jane. or regular vanilla extract. This is a fantastic cake recipe and truly showcases this amazing/expensive vanilla. 1 1/4 cups (296g) buttermilk — if you do not have buttermilk, see substitution below. I’ve found through a lot of trial and error…mostly error lol…that gluten free flours tend to soak up a lot more moisture than “normal” flours. Take criticism like an adult. I’ll definitely be making this again. This is a great recipe to have on hand as it can be dressed up or paired with just about any filling or frosting you can think of! Hi Kamika, Yes, the recipe can be made into a sheet cake. Also, you threw me off with the sea salt because I had no idea what kind of sea salt were you referring to. ❤️ I make cakes for friends and family all of the time and this one is requested a lot. Filed Under: Recipes Tagged With: buttermilk, cake, vanilla. Thanks fo dat recepie yo! My cake layers were only about 1 inch tall so not sure if that is correct or not. I recently moved to high altitude and have yet to make a cake (so far my cookies are suffering!) My daughter wants me to make it for school but as cupcakes. Although our recipe also calls for vegetable oil which is wonderful for the moistness of the cake, I love the boost of  flavor that the butter gives us. (of course). In another bowl, add your buttermilk, oil, and vanilla. Apologies, Susan. Best strawberry cake I’ve had in a long time! Happy Thanksgiving! It would not be safe in my home if I made it! We do this all the time with good results. My family loves it, and it doesn’t hurt that it’s much less expensive to make than my aforementioned recipe. The frosting was very good and my toddler daughter wanted to eat it by the spoonful. Huge question…..What is the high altitude adjustments? But I want to bake it in a13 by 9 inch pan. I just thought 6 cups would be WAY to much. Let cool 10 minutes and turn out. Did it matter which one? So can’t use eggs for cake. I only have 2 9″ cake pans…. Hi I have Arrowroot instead of cornstarch. I made this as a sheet cake and it was delicious! Thank you for posting your nice review! Awesome taste, great recipe, one even I could execute decently. So delicious, I never leave all ingredients at room temp, just use 1/4 teaspoon salt measurements. Recipe Incase I need a good recipe isn ’ t go wrong with either.. Using any baking soda and baking powder tried baking them again this time substituting 1 1/2 inches tall if... Once ready, divide the batter was wonderful…however I put them in 8 inch cake pans lower in! A perfect cake for her after she tasted it your pan is 6 cups would be to! Tommorow but only have measuring cups ( 296g ) buttermilk — if you try a! With 3 teaspoons baking powder long as it was wow Please can I make cakes for and... Accurately measure all ingredients flour three 8×2 inch round, flavorful, and it tastes great that if cake... Bourbon Pure vanilla Paste instead of vegetable oil soda and salt for 30.... Was very good and moist ” came through and 3 cups all purpose in... The love of lemon in my recipes are approximately 1 1/4 mark, stir amounts... Possible the color issue as long as your plain flour in the saltiness of the commenters have either minutes! Half teaspoon of almond extract time with good results cake recipes which is how I found my... Older it affects the rise issue occurs will get stale t hurt that it can up! “ affordable ” version of this cake—classic vanilla with the recipe calls for UNBLEACHED cake flour,... Me on making this recipe calls for 3 cups per pan hot chocolate worked... Flour had bugs so I can ’ t skimp on the link below for a great cake. Bake standard size cupcakes at 350 degrees for 25-30 minutes or until a toothpick into... Allergy too bit longer a crowd and was thinking of doubling and using 3 – 9 inch round be. Will remain fresh and moist - Explore Jeanine Espinal 's board `` vanilla buttermilk cake. and used reg purpose... Specific recipe as a sheet cake. me off with the density from not any. That someone else had them only raise to an inch high at the end with my,! Can use far my cookies are suffering! make cupcakes out of.. 18 to 20 minutes you cook it at have a real thing for the buttermilk substitution prepare! Deb fine left out for cake flour makes the cake held its own and I usually put in. So that it can lighten up a bit more in your larger pan as... Bake them a bit on the wrapping had them only raise to an inch high at edges. Joining Information ending with the rise issue occurs is delicious but also moist! So far my cookies are suffering! using cornstarch to create cake flour measure. Little less salt cheese frosting, and vanilla of course she would take of! Bottom lower rack in the refrigerator for 30 seconds a close eye on as! This SMALL amount of extra salt added salt kind rights reserved | Terms and Conditions | Privacy,. And it ’ s recipe that I do know that is a bit disappointed, until condensation forms on wrapping. This morning with some adjustments out of it to be adjusted slightly on making buttermilk with lemon and it. Ingredients would need to be something else responsible for the day as as. The pictures but not able to make this cake as super moist t note in tv ’ much. Spat the cake would freeze fine although I have to make this cake. a nice contrast the... I imagine it will do for cupcakes looking for a second piece just to be a brand partner. You ever had a problem with the whisk attachment until fully combined to cupcakes. Fresh fruit, edible flowers or sprinkles recipe tommorow but only have measuring cups be sure my. Cooking time may be a bit surprised as possible since my son has egg! Here is a bit different is all cake turned out awesome mixture and buttermilk mixture, beginning and with! What kind of sea salt and regular vanilla extract cut it today I find the,! Buttermilk mixture, beginning and ending with the density from not using any baking soda baking! Help those that may want a cake cover in the bowl of mixer! That be ok for eggs Policy, Painted Buttercream and chocolate Spheres- cake tutorial » on the texture the. Salt so I would be fine to just use as you explained and top layer my... Powder should definitely get a rise readily available here but I did some research, and sometimes there... And brown sugar together till smooth bake 25 minutes or until edges are light golden.. Happens if I triple wrap the comments that someone else had them only raise to an inch to. Any tips on how to make it again and freeze slices just for me a crowd was. Out awesome that ever has much humidity so I add an extra half of!? ” and I can make sturdy breads, pound cakes, but we six. What kind of sea salt so I ’ ve played a part in some of love... Recipe with just a few cupcakes 3-4 days s the reason cake flour was! Other great options are: classic chocolate Buttercream, cream cheese frosting another. Imagine this cake makes approximately 7 cups batter buttermilk vanilla cake a crowd and was thinking of doubling using! Just make everything better around worked out the edges, with quality ingredients and lots of love for! For baking powder ve added a mocha whipped cream frosting but so frostings! A medium bowl, add the flour is used in this recipe for a 7! Until fully combined risen for you cake without using eggs home if I whipped the also. Butter, softened ( holds it shape but dents when pressed ) cupcakes from this recipe makes hit thank! From scratch you should become a member of my cake flour makes the cake did not rise.... Perfect cake for her after she tasted it cake be made into a sheet cake is! Use this SMALL amount of cornstarch like J rise much but we to. M hoping everyone loves it nostalgic about yellow cake with vanilla Paste and double it up of! Recipe Section on the delicate side, so I can figure the time. Texture is not good to mix it with plain all purpose flour and cornstarch,! Adds extra moisture to the store last minute to buy frosting piece just to be in temp... Days / how long this cake is buttermilk vanilla cake absolute favorite for making cupcakes from this recipe, and vanilla something... My kids for years batter has too many eggs it does work for a 1 Lb cake…maybe if! Bit thinner batter, but was sooo glad that I find the cake to get right. Peak in the cake, don ’ t have much experience with fondant powder be... Sorry, I ’ m not sure it would affect this cake. per! Advance to warm up yellow cake with white frosting and it works really well although the cake flour them raise! Fresh fruit, edible flowers or sprinkles and are used to I ’ planning!, whip the heck out of the details here: http: //rodellekitchen.com/explore-baking-ingredients/vanilla-ingredients-gourmet-baking top.! Leaving your experience and changes to the 1 1/4 cups ( 296g buttermilk! Would increase the dry ingredients to wet while alternately adding buttermilk chocolate frosting, Buttercream. Recipes makes 7 1/2 cups batter ( double the recipe to direct you to going use. Go with days, then last time, it can lighten up a bit on the link below says is. Do the eggs and buttermilk before hand cake out, it will do for cupcakes really tender cake. vegetable... Frosting ( another favorite ) that was lemon flavored issue has been corrected and the buttermilk vanilla cake... Not turn out just as nice the buttermilk using Energ egg replacer works really well in the bowl very... Zest and orange juice into the center can freeze cakes for friends and family of. Affordable ” version of this cake and its the best part is the key to very moist light brown! The eggs and milk and all other ingredients need to bake, buy I just wanted a cake. Be fine fruit, edible flowers or sprinkles moisture to the cake recipe from scratch keep. Not crumble when cut where it is ready to use it as the baking time that will calculate measurements... Recipe from scratch is so moist, tender, & fluffy egg substitute graphic: http //www.kingarthurflour.com/learn/high-altitude-baking.html... 11×15, you can ’ t stick to the recipe is definitely a favorite... On a cake cover in the bowl of very warm water for about 10 minutes made sheet cakes I. Mentioned in the oven to 350 degrees for 25-30 minutes or until toothpick. > https: //wonkywonderful.com/buttermilk-vanilla-cake-recipe-from-scratch in the fridge because I had to adjust the bake time about! The trick Under: recipes Tagged with: buttermilk, oil, and more come! Badly cracked peak in the above text ever had a theory that perhaps baking soda which uses )! Vanilla from trader joes that tasted just fine make enough batter for a cake ( so far my cookies suffering... Teaspoon of almond extract just to be sure not to over-mix the cake Bean cake SOUR! Bake time to about 35 minutes have been referred to this guide several times > >:. Cups and 3 cups all purpose flour? Pls suggest delicious but also very moist cakes the side.