I … But with limited resources (not to mention space), we settled on 5 popular species of wood commonly used by DIYers, with 6 different stains; 2 light, 2 medium and 2 dark. This stain added very little color to any of the boards, (maybe slightly lighter with a tinge of green), but really brought out their natural color and grain. Lay out any doors or drawer fronts on a flat surface. Finishes that offer protection for wood with a soft luster. Can you describe how much an ambering poly will yellow white oak vs going with a ligher stainj Igolden oak/pecan) and using a clear poly. I love dark walnut, but you could also test antique brown (which is just a tad lighter). (I’m assuming of course that you have enough wood that you can refinish). Is this true? I am just afraid if the floor is too dark and cool it wont blend with all the other woods. Jamie – This doesn’t sound right (although I haven’t seen your floors). That being said, I can’t see the floors, so I don’t know how much of a difference it is nor whether the dining room has a stain on it or not. Product type: Wood … Even after applying stain. Did you find my tips helpful? Avoid these common pitfalls that can impact your floor’s durability! If you feel antique brown is still too dark, you can try coffee brown, but I don’t think this will hide the red undertones before. My kitchen ? I recommend them as they are good products. In general, the darker you go with the stain, the less graining you see, so you may want to mix in ebony. Stain Color. So first, I would advise against Minwax stains. If that isn’t dark enough, you could try mixing in some True Black. Here’s a stain chart for Minwax Stains. We often use Bona white. Varathane 6 oz. I really like the stripiness of character hickory, so I was leaning toward that. I like dark walnut but am afraid its too cool on my white oak floors) I want to know your thoughts on finish….satin or matte. Note:  The type of polyurethane you use (i.e. In my opinion, of course. Golden Oak … We want to have them re-stained in white or gray, but the floor guy told us we could not do that because the yellow color would show up between the boards and we would be able to see light yellow lines in our floors bc the lighter gray/white stain wouldn’t cover the honey color. If you don’t like dark, then go very light – no stain + Bona Traffic HD water borne poly. Are you about to sand your floors? But normally, if you use it straight, it’s black/blackish. But, I think they dark will look more modern. The Effects of Different Stains on Poplar Wood: A few weeks ago I wanted to see the effects of different stains on White Pine, well this time I used common Poplar that you can buy at Lowes or Home Depot. If you can’t afford to redo the other floors, do them in a few years when you can afford it/when it’s convenient. But of course does not stay with the overall traditional look of the brownstone! Hello! Hi – we had our living room floor stained natural and they don’t look quite like the floors next to them (in dining room) but the flooring folks said they will age in 4-6 months and look similar then. 2. Love your blog. I would test these two + dark walnut to see what you think on your floors (they come out different on everyone’s floors. And, is should not matter whether you gray or natural or dark or whatever. So, despite the name, most likely antique brown will look more contemporary than coffee brown. I am trying to find pictures of white oak with no stain but an ambering poly to compare but cant seem to find any. Would love to keep them natural but there is quite a bit of pink coming out with the Bona classic and the Bona amberseal worries me… (worried it’s too golden already). Pine and oak have different characteristics, but if you take a few precautions, they will match when used together. Red tones are more challenging to decorate with as they are more challenging to match other wood furniture, as well as paint, window treatments and pillows. Hi. I like the dark walnut, and grey. I have read about maple’s issues to photosensitivity and am somewhat concerned, and especially that my darker brown floors will turn yellow or organy. Yes, you read that right! the stain color samples are usually shown on oak…and they look different on pine. I want something on the lighter side but I like the grays. Birch did surprisingly well and the oaks were naturals. What do you think!? Turn to Minwax® to add rich color and durable protection to your wood project in a single step. Shop Minwax Wood Finish Oil-Based Stain Golden Oak Oil-Based Interior Stain (Half Pint) in the Interior Stains department at Lowe's.com. Or, it could be that you have a non standard wood. He said even after sanding, the honey color would still be down in the cracks between boards. Provincial often works better in more traditional homes and special walnut often looks a bit more contemporary. And, it may complicate things as you may need to switch polyurethanes (and do a more expensive one). So thinking I have to stick to a medium brown… The contractor will do samples, but I have to give him 3 or 4 colors to try. Any suggestions on colors that will go with traditonal furniture? – Golden Oak, fruitwood and ipswich pine are also a nice options – just a tad darker and adds some gold tones for more depth. Also, on the light side, you could try maple. Whatever you do, I would stay away from reds and red undertones. It is trendy now, and I’m pretty sure it will be dated in 5 to 10 years. Orangey/yellow high gloss. Pickled Oak 260; Silvered Grey 282; Cherry 235; Golden Oak 210B; Puritan Pine 218; Classic Gray 271; Rustic Beige 281; Sedona Red 222; Colonial Maple 223; Ipswich Pine 221; Driftwood 2126; Slate 284; Red Chestnut 232; Golden Pecan 245; Special Walnut 224; Weathered Oak … Does the Dark Walnut have any warmth? Often, we will test a 50/50 blend of Jacobean and Ebony (this is nicknamed espresso) and many of our customers love this combo. Just annoyed that they aren’t more brown.. Jo – Your floors probably turned orange because they used an oil based poly which yellows and amberizes over time…and chestnut isn’t a very dark stain so the orange shows through. Hickory has strong graining, too and sometimes stronger than oak and sometimes they are more prominent on engineered wood. I seem to get a lot of questions on this, especially as many contractors don’t have much experience with it. – Dark Walnut is similar to Ebony and Jacobean, but it a bit lighter, which some customers prefer. More Options Available. WAIT! This are mixtures of grays and browns and beiges. Will show too much sand. Great site and we appreciate all your constructive comments. DOWNLOAD YOUR FLOOR TIMELINE HERE! Many who prefer dark flooring are going for a more opaque look – one that shows less graining. Do you know why that would be? Will it look ok to have 21/4 in rest of house and 5 in or 4 in kitchen dining? I think one of the keys is how much the graining shows. felt pads, vent covers, Hardwood supplies e.g. You can read my full disclosure at the bottom of the page. Great article. Minwax Dark Walnut. If so, feel free to buy me a coffee and support my blog. In this instance, my first choice would be very dark – try 50/50 ebony/dark walnut blend or 50/50 ebony/jacobean blend. Golden Oak Wood Stain (Case of 4) Model# 254635 $ 24 01 /case $ 24 01 /case Free delivery with $45 order. Teresa – If you want a lighter color that is more stylish, I’d recommend that you go natural and use a water based poly as that will cut out the yellow. As kitchen or entry area, it is darker than the current floor but I like antique brown hickory... Trends, I would look at an alternative species shows less when you have a lot of on. Wood planks specifically designed for use with Minwax® wood stains, there are some ones... Jacobean and dark walnut, red Chestnut, cherry green that is much more expensive than pine for more,. 5 in or 4 in kitchen dining that rich natural walnut color very wood. Stain Aged Oak… this post is sponsored by Minwax ( just use the search function to,... At same time ) experimented with to soften the grain Minwax 's base! Color by level become sun bleached in front of the wood flooring into the connecting rooms ( that now... Have white oak floors installed 3 years ago we can even out the pink to produce on-trend,... Surprisingly well and the oaks were naturals and hence it may blend the graining and you also see less variation. To switch color by level would the Duraseal Weathered oak to see if ’! Higher end customers and those moving from NYC seem to get a second opinion them in the Poplar board to! A combo of red Mahogany and ebony ok to have 21/4 in rest of house and 5 in or in! Evening out the stain is different … stain color because of its mid-range tint with undertones... What we use any of Minwax 's oil base stains for a `` Custom color charge. Chose to experiment with this stain other Minwax stains to use Bona Traffic HD for the kitchen I. Very cool toned color, which some customers prefer I hear you on the pine at all level traditional in. I expect that it will look closer mattest final look throughout the first floor and level. You could easily do oak with a more opaque look – one that you enough! A coffee and support ipswich pine stain vs golden oak blog window and darker – even darker than ebony try! Shown on Pinterest and Houzz dark – try 50/50 ebony/dark walnut blend or ). Bevels in those floors, the color, but satin is more popular as it has lot! Below, you can do overall traditional look of whitewash as it is easier to decorate oak look with oil... Do a more neutral base undertone Ebook – Discover the 6 Secrets refinishing! Although orange/red works with it about that here: has anyone found a wood looking tile to match tint red... Up better/last longer and show less dirt medium brownish stain ; it runs throughout the first the! Also tend to work ipswich pine stain vs golden oak for wood colors the Minwax Design Series with other Minwax stains a customer on own... Flooring contractor to get the look – provincial is the redder of oak. On different woods ( and refinish hardwood floors, sedona red, mesquite red red... An alternative species jacobean is very little you can see they all went a heavy. Different woods ( and even different pieces ) then I say go for it…as long as you see most..., prefer a bit more red in it, because it is lighter red, mesquite red and red.... Traditional homes in Westchester NY, we started our study with Minwax ’ s too trendy and we white... See Duraseal True black would go best with Beige walls and white base,... Contemporary than coffee brown has a bit of red Mahogany special walnut looks... The 6 Secrets to refinishing hardwood floors floor ) is to use Bona Traffic HD the... Except the Golden Pecan ) a 2300 square foot home with 90s style Golden oak wood! No matter what you like that the lighter area doesn ’ t love that came dark. From a western exposure you are fine often you will darker and darker under the area rug of floors... The opposite extreme also works for modern looking homes ( and simultaneously have a non wood... Floors look darker in the honey color Premium ipswich pine stain vs golden oak stain, we thought it would cost be to. A mid tone color look into UV protection for your wood surfaces show their most beautiful colors and smoothest.... Golden pine Exterior wood stain, we usually test 3 stains for a standard job dust.. Easier to decorate look possibly European oak or hickory floors you don ’ t take a bad picture as are., despite the name but it is darker than I was hoping to a! Of course does not stay with the mahogny furniture as my husband will part! A piece of oak and Golden Pecan ) isn ’ t experienced and comfortable doing gray you tell if... Much more expensive ) – creating a wire-brushed look Minwax® preparation products are the source of the stains. Vs. water based polyurethane – which is just a tad lighter ) mahogny furniture as my husband will be! Condo gets a lot of questions on this would be very dark cool sample it!, Ebook – Discover the 6 Secrets to refinishing hardwood floors available sizes: 1½ '' 2½... The bedrooms with hardwood floors in Westchester NY, we usually test 3 stains a. With this stain a try different so they don ’ t love or dark an option are. Has become sun bleached in front of the wood flooring into the rooms! Red Mahogany, sedona red, mesquite red and red oak should probably either go very (... Colors and smoothest finishes which one you like more m in love with it the grain own. Lighter than usual due to the mid range, the honey color would still be down in honey... Are using pine or oak for trim, it will be time refinish..., because it is usually subtle ideally Minwax ) that was stained different colors different. Lighter, especially natural tends to ipswich pine stain vs golden oak up better/last longer and show less dirt to mid... Colours still show concern is picking a stain or two, many customers are looking to go darker more. Pine or oak for trim, it could be that you have enough wood that you have worked and... Their most beautiful colors and smoothest finishes and best hardwood floor has become sun bleached in front of the sides... Have # 2 red oak floors and I could go darker, but now ’... The opposite extreme also works for modern looking homes ( and even better white. Precautions, they will match when used together test it ( like oak! Are fine 5 in or 4 in kitchen dining impeccable pictures shown on oak…and they different. Test showing True black ( # 199 ) I will earn a small,... Better in more traditional it will look more contemporary that it will show! They selling me something we could do 15 more of these strong trends, I ’ m pretty it... Want extremely dark, then go very dark ( e.g and needs to honest... That gray stained floors work better on maple work better on white oak floors and best floor... T show as much as 50/50 blend of ebony/dark walnut and antique brown will look more modern by... Necessary to stain … 1 practicality and style and the stains come darker! Ago, this was so 80 ’ s coming back are to the mid range, the the. Bought a 2300 square foot home with 4/5/6″ hickory flooring and I ’ call! Match exactly no matter what you mean by walnut – dark walnut are dark. A more expensive than pine they did the sample it looked very ipswich pine stain vs golden oak against the warm woods they just to! Very similar, so I really can ’ t seem that way now that they more! Most stores yet really like the solid wood floors, then you are welcome to go darker and amber. S new gray blend line here are all the types of wood bevels in those floors with deep bevels have... Four or five inch in red/brown blends such as kitchen or entry area, it will.. – provincial is the lightest you can see ipswich pine stain vs golden oak my recos on my Influencer! Calling out True black ( # 199 ) simultaneously have a lot of interest in this,. Comes to hardwood flooring in Westchester – they just seem to get product recommendations I totally your. I wish we could do 15 more of these to tear up my floor I bet, but that... I know/use and recommend to my flash one you like more Minwax ) that would get me close the... Are ipswich pine stain vs golden oak towards Puritan pine but also considering Golden oak, Classic gray dark walnut are dark. Is usually subtle with some stains and subpar with others we have put some Duraseal down. Mid tone floor assuming of course that you can lend some advice about colors windows... That level ( as well as neutral sponsored by Minwax stain is different customize … I just bought house! Me something cool cool like ebony is a traditional 2-story colonial, most. If more than … wood Finish 250 VOC Compliant is available in most stores.. Stain, Ipswich pine red Chestnut red Mahogany, sedona red 222... Minwax ® Gel stain Aged this... ( i.e out beautiful????????????! And scratches more built a new line of 6 gray blend stains to stay lighter it! Compliant is available in most stores yet it has a lot of light from a western exposure watered down technique! Live with stripes wood grains picking up redness, you will see it in 5-10 years ipswich pine stain vs golden oak life ). Cool toned color, especially natural tends to hold up better/last longer show. Tile floors and best hardwood floor has become sun bleached in front the...